American Sound Studio recordings – The ‘3 albums’ project

Talk about Elvis Presley. Anything goes. Anything? Yes, really!
Post Reply
User avatar
Troubleman
Posts: 20
Joined: July 30th, 2025, 11:49 am
Has thanked: 12 times
Been thanked: 34 times

American Sound Studio recordings – The ‘3 albums’ project

Post by Troubleman »

We can all agree that the 1969 American Sound recordings are some of the best work that Elvis has ever done. The results were 2 great albums, great singles, and the rest of the songs were spread out on budget albums, or later releases.

Some of us would probably change a few songs on the ‘From Elvis in Memphis’ album, while others would leave it just the way it is. The same for the ‘Back in Memphis’ album, which I always thought was lost coupled with the ‘Live at the International Hotel’ double album.

I suggest this fun exercise as to how you would have released the 32 cuts made at American Sound if you were tasked to do so. So let’s pretend you work for RCA and you get the tracks all mixed, overdubbed, and ready to go.

So the bosses at RCA give you the following instructions:

- They want all tracks released on 3 albums. The weaker tracks will be ‘album fillers’, but they want everything released.
- The first 2 albums will be released in 1969 (summer and fall) and the last one at the beginning of 1970.
- Each album must have some cohesion. In other words, it cannot sound like a bunch of ‘leftover’s songs put together.
- Each album must have a least one potential ‘Hit single’ that will be released ahead of the album to promote it.
- You can come up with any title you want for each album.

Image

Image

Image

If it was me, I would create one album with a ‘Soul’ feel to it, one with more ‘Pop/rock’ tunes, and one ‘Country sounding’ album. So these would be my choices:

Album 1 – From Elvis in Memphis

Side 1
1. Wearin’ that loved on look (2:46)
2. True love travels on a gravel road (2:38)
3. After loving you (3:06)
4. Do you know who I am? (2:48)
5. Power of my love (2:36)
6. In the Ghetto (2:45)

Side 2
1. Long black limousine (3:38)
2. Only the strong survive (2:42)
3. Stranger in my own home town (4:22)
4. Without love (There is nothing) (2:52)
5. The fair’s moving on (3:08)

Album 2 – Back in Memphis

Side 1
1. Suspicious minds (4:29)
2. Any day now (2:59)
3. Who am I? (3:18)
4. And the grass won’t pay no mind (3:09)
5. A little bit of green (3:28)

Side 2
1. Don’t cry daddy (2:48)
2. Rubberneckin’ (2:09)
3. This is the story (2:28)
4. Hey Jude (4:30)
5. I’ll be there (2:22)
6. Mama liked the roses (2:47)

Album 3 – Elvis at American Sound Studio

Side 1
1. Kentucky rain (3:14)
2. From a Jack to a King (2:24)
3. I’ll hold you in my heart (4:32)
4. If I’m a fool (For loving you) (2:43)
5. My little friend (2:45)

Side 2
1. Inherit the wind (2:56)
2. I’m movin’ on (2:52)
3. Gentle on my mind (3:21)
4. It keeps right on-a hurtin’ (2:36)
5. You’ll think of me (4:00)

The 3rd album would not be as great as the first 2, but good, nonetheless. So what would be your albums?

Alternate third album: Elvis at American Sound Studio (songs not featured on the 2 released albums)

Side 1 (15:33)
1. Suspicious minds (4:29)
2. I’ll be there (2:22)
3. Kentucky rain (3:14)
4. If I’m a fool (For loving you) (2:43)
5. My little friend (2:45)

Side 2 (15:32)
1. Don’t cry daddy (2:48)
2. Rubberneckin’ (2:09)
3. Mama liked the roses (2:47)
4. Hey Jude (4:30)
5. Who am I? (3:18)
Troubleman
User avatar
DayVeeBee
Posts: 3
Joined: July 28th, 2025, 12:19 pm
Has thanked: 22 times
Been thanked: 4 times

Re: American Sound Studio recordings – The ‘3 albums’ project

Post by DayVeeBee »

I would substitute "Clean up your own Backyard" for "Hey Jude" in every case!
Sweet-Angeline
Posts: 52
Joined: August 1st, 2025, 5:37 am
Has thanked: 44 times
Been thanked: 77 times

Re: American Sound Studio recordings – The ‘3 albums’ project

Post by Sweet-Angeline »

DayVeeBee wrote: September 17th, 2025, 10:02 am I would substitute "Clean up your own Backyard" for "Hey Jude" in every case!
...at American Sound Studios?? I learn something new everyday ;)
User avatar
DayVeeBee
Posts: 3
Joined: July 28th, 2025, 12:19 pm
Has thanked: 22 times
Been thanked: 4 times

Re: American Sound Studio recordings – The ‘3 albums’ project

Post by DayVeeBee »

I know I'm cheating a little, but I don't count Hey Jude as a worthy master! And I love Clean Up ;)
User avatar
rockinrebel
Posts: 4
Joined: August 31st, 2025, 2:58 pm
Has thanked: 7 times
Been thanked: 2 times

Re: American Sound Studio recordings – The ‘3 albums’ project

Post by rockinrebel »

Despite the undoubted quality of the sessions, I think three albums is too much of a stretch. I think they got it right with two albums, and using the rest of the tracks across B sides and budget titles. And the same thing should have been done with the June 1970 recordings.

The only thing I would have changed is the addition of non album single A sides to Back In Memphis.
Sweet-Angeline
Posts: 52
Joined: August 1st, 2025, 5:37 am
Has thanked: 44 times
Been thanked: 77 times

Re: American Sound Studio recordings – The ‘3 albums’ project

Post by Sweet-Angeline »

DayVeeBee wrote: September 18th, 2025, 11:47 am I know I'm cheating a little, but I don't count Hey Jude as a worthy master! And I love Clean Up ;)
Clean Up Your Own Backyard is a great track!! and takes on a life of it`s own outside the film :D
FanFrom'61
Posts: 87
Joined: August 5th, 2025, 9:09 am
Location: UK
Has thanked: 17 times
Been thanked: 64 times

Re: American Sound Studio recordings – The ‘3 albums’ project

Post by FanFrom'61 »

DayVeeBee wrote: September 18th, 2025, 11:47 am I know I'm cheating a little, but I don't count Hey Jude as a worthy master! And I love Clean Up ;)
Hey Jude should not be regarded as a master and should not have appeared on any studio album as such - it should have remained on the shelf to make an appearance on some kind of rarities album further down the line. And whilst Clean Up is a really good track, I doesn’t deserve a place on any American Studio Memphis album as it was recorded in October ‘68 at United Studios, Hollywood.
Sweet-Angeline
Posts: 52
Joined: August 1st, 2025, 5:37 am
Has thanked: 44 times
Been thanked: 77 times

Re: American Sound Studio recordings – The ‘3 albums’ project

Post by Sweet-Angeline »

FanFrom'61 wrote: September 19th, 2025, 1:13 pm
DayVeeBee wrote: September 18th, 2025, 11:47 am I know I'm cheating a little, but I don't count Hey Jude as a worthy master! And I love Clean Up ;)
Hey Jude should not be regarded as a master and should not have appeared on any studio album as such - it should have remained on the shelf to make an appearance on some kind of rarities album further down the line. And whilst Clean Up is a really good track, I doesn’t deserve a place on any American Studio Memphis album as it was recorded in October ‘68 at United Studios, Hollywood.
...and we knew this already ;)
FanFrom'61
Posts: 87
Joined: August 5th, 2025, 9:09 am
Location: UK
Has thanked: 17 times
Been thanked: 64 times

Re: American Sound Studio recordings – The ‘3 albums’ project

Post by FanFrom'61 »

Sweet-Angeline wrote: September 19th, 2025, 7:51 pm
FanFrom'61 wrote: September 19th, 2025, 1:13 pm
DayVeeBee wrote: September 18th, 2025, 11:47 am I know I'm cheating a little, but I don't count Hey Jude as a worthy master! And I love Clean Up ;)
Hey Jude should not be regarded as a master and should not have appeared on any studio album as such - it should have remained on the shelf to make an appearance on some kind of rarities album further down the line. And whilst Clean Up is a really good track, I doesn’t deserve a place on any American Studio Memphis album as it was recorded in October ‘68 at United Studios, Hollywood.
...and we knew this already ;)
Did we? Are you sure? The OP seemed pretty emphatic about its inclusion.
User avatar
Troubleman
Posts: 20
Joined: July 30th, 2025, 11:49 am
Has thanked: 12 times
Been thanked: 34 times

Re: American Sound Studio recordings – The ‘3 albums’ project

Post by Troubleman »

I know that many don't like 'Hey Jude' but this would not be the first jam that would be released on an album. The songs 'I'll hold you in my heart', 'Got my mojo working', 'Don't think twice, it's all right' and 'Merry Christmas, baby' were pretty much Elvis jamming, but they were used as album fillers.

Instead of using 'Clean up your own backyard' (which I love as well) they could have used 'Let's be friends' recorded in March of 69 for the movie Change of Habit, but was not used.
Troubleman
FanFrom'61
Posts: 87
Joined: August 5th, 2025, 9:09 am
Location: UK
Has thanked: 17 times
Been thanked: 64 times

Re: American Sound Studio recordings – The ‘3 albums’ project

Post by FanFrom'61 »

Troubleman wrote: September 21st, 2025, 8:16 am I know that many don't like 'Hey Jude' but this would not be the first jam that would be released on an album. The songs 'I'll hold you in my heart', 'Got my mojo working', 'Don't think twice, it's all right' and 'Merry Christmas, baby' were pretty much Elvis jamming, but they were used as album fillers.

Instead of using 'Clean up your own backyard' (which I love as well) they could have used 'Let's be friends' recorded in March of 69 for the movie Change of Habit, but was not used.
Whilst the thread is about creating three albums from all tracks by including fillers across all three, it means there is a danger of wreaking the albums. As has been mentioned, two albums from the Memphis sessions is adequate, although I believe Suspicious Minds should have been included on Back in Memphis despite Parker’s assertions against it due to duplications. If you have to include non Memphis recordings in an attempt to create a third Memphis album, then you’ve failed with the brief.
User avatar
Troubleman
Posts: 20
Joined: July 30th, 2025, 11:49 am
Has thanked: 12 times
Been thanked: 34 times

Re: American Sound Studio recordings – The ‘3 albums’ project

Post by Troubleman »

FanFrom'61 wrote: September 21st, 2025, 8:58 am
Troubleman wrote: September 21st, 2025, 8:16 am I know that many don't like 'Hey Jude' but this would not be the first jam that would be released on an album. The songs 'I'll hold you in my heart', 'Got my mojo working', 'Don't think twice, it's all right' and 'Merry Christmas, baby' were pretty much Elvis jamming, but they were used as album fillers.

Instead of using 'Clean up your own backyard' (which I love as well) they could have used 'Let's be friends' recorded in March of 69 for the movie Change of Habit, but was not used.
Whilst the thread is about creating three albums from all tracks by including fillers across all three, it means there is a danger of wreaking the albums. As has been mentioned, two albums from the Memphis sessions is adequate, although I believe Suspicious Minds should have been included on Back in Memphis despite Parker’s assertions against it due to duplications. If you have to include non Memphis recordings in an attempt to create a third Memphis album, then you’ve failed with the brief.
i was responding to the idea of replacing 'Hey Jude' with 'Clean up your own backyard' as was suggested. I always thought it was ashamed that songs like 'Suspicious minds', 'Don't cry daddy' and 'Kentucky rain' never made it on a regular album. I know that 'Kentucky rain, ended up on the 'Pure gold' album in 1975, but the LP was more a compilation of older songs than a regular LP. With 32 songs recorded, i thought that there was enough good material for at least a 3rd album.
Troubleman
FanFrom'61
Posts: 87
Joined: August 5th, 2025, 9:09 am
Location: UK
Has thanked: 17 times
Been thanked: 64 times

Re: American Sound Studio recordings – The ‘3 albums’ project

Post by FanFrom'61 »

Troubleman wrote: September 21st, 2025, 10:03 am
FanFrom'61 wrote: September 21st, 2025, 8:58 am
Troubleman wrote: September 21st, 2025, 8:16 am I know that many don't like 'Hey Jude' but this would not be the first jam that would be released on an album. The songs 'I'll hold you in my heart', 'Got my mojo working', 'Don't think twice, it's all right' and 'Merry Christmas, baby' were pretty much Elvis jamming, but they were used as album fillers.

Instead of using 'Clean up your own backyard' (which I love as well) they could have used 'Let's be friends' recorded in March of 69 for the movie Change of Habit, but was not used.
Whilst the thread is about creating three albums from all tracks by including fillers across all three, it means there is a danger of wreaking the albums. As has been mentioned, two albums from the Memphis sessions is adequate, although I believe Suspicious Minds should have been included on Back in Memphis despite Parker’s assertions against it due to duplications. If you have to include non Memphis recordings in an attempt to create a third Memphis album, then you’ve failed with the brief.
i was responding to the idea of replacing 'Hey Jude' with 'Clean up your own backyard' as was suggested. I always thought it was ashamed that songs like 'Suspicious minds', 'Don't cry daddy' and 'Kentucky rain' never made it on a regular album. I know that 'Kentucky rain, ended up on the 'Pure gold' album in 1975, but the LP was more a compilation of older songs than a regular LP. With 32 songs recorded, i thought that there was enough good material for at least a 3rd album.
I know what you were responding to, but substituting Clean Up for another non American Studio recording does not meet the brief that the OP started off with. That said, I would never had tried to squeeze a third album out of the 32 songs because the leftovers were basically leftovers for a reason. Including them within the first two albums would have weakened those and a third album would have ended up being weak too.
User avatar
rockinrebel
Posts: 4
Joined: August 31st, 2025, 2:58 pm
Has thanked: 7 times
Been thanked: 2 times

Re: American Sound Studio recordings – The ‘3 albums’ project

Post by rockinrebel »

FanFrom'61 wrote: September 21st, 2025, 10:18 am
Troubleman wrote: September 21st, 2025, 10:03 am
FanFrom'61 wrote: September 21st, 2025, 8:58 am
Troubleman wrote: September 21st, 2025, 8:16 am I know that many don't like 'Hey Jude' but this would not be the first jam that would be released on an album. The songs 'I'll hold you in my heart', 'Got my mojo working', 'Don't think twice, it's all right' and 'Merry Christmas, baby' were pretty much Elvis jamming, but they were used as album fillers.

Instead of using 'Clean up your own backyard' (which I love as well) they could have used 'Let's be friends' recorded in March of 69 for the movie Change of Habit, but was not used.
Whilst the thread is about creating three albums from all tracks by including fillers across all three, it means there is a danger of wreaking the albums. As has been mentioned, two albums from the Memphis sessions is adequate, although I believe Suspicious Minds should have been included on Back in Memphis despite Parker’s assertions against it due to duplications. If you have to include non Memphis recordings in an attempt to create a third Memphis album, then you’ve failed with the brief.
i was responding to the idea of replacing 'Hey Jude' with 'Clean up your own backyard' as was suggested. I always thought it was ashamed that songs like 'Suspicious minds', 'Don't cry daddy' and 'Kentucky rain' never made it on a regular album. I know that 'Kentucky rain, ended up on the 'Pure gold' album in 1975, but the LP was more a compilation of older songs than a regular LP. With 32 songs recorded, i thought that there was enough good material for at least a 3rd album.
I know what you were responding to, but substituting Clean Up for another non American Studio recording does not meet the brief that the OP started off with. That said, I would never had tried to squeeze a third album out of the 32 songs because the leftovers were basically leftovers for a reason. Including them within the first two albums would have weakened those and a third album would have ended up being weak too.
And this was the problem with the Colonel's approach to marketing Elvis. Release everything he recorded - good, bad or indifferent and squeeze as many albums as you can out of each session. Not surprisingly therefore, the quality of subsequent albums varied considerably.

In respect of the jam sessions, whilst some of these were charming, if they were going to use them on mainstream albums they could have done a little more post production work.

Don't Think Twice on Fool fades in and out, and nobody bothered to create a proper intro until Our Memories of Elvis Vol.2 in 1979.

Whilst Mojo on Love Letters starts abruptly where the tape starts, which doesn't make for the best listening experience either. And the less said about Hey Jude on Elvis Now the better.

The attitude to completling albums was that anything goes as long as it met the criteria of 10 tracks. This is why Sony find themselves creating 'new' albums now, rather than celebrating the originals...
Post Reply

Create an account or sign in to join the discussion

You need to be a member in order to post a reply

Create an account

Not a member? register to join our community
Members can start their own topics & subscribe to topics
It’s free and only takes a minute

Register

Sign in